David Kassir

The planning considerations behind my comments on the Medicare increase and the 2027 Social Security raise

David KassirManaging Director of Manna Wealth Management
Expert Commentary / Retirement

The planning considerations behind my comments on the Medicare increase and the 2027 Social Security raise

Quoted in Newsweek: How Medicare Hike Will Eat Into Social Security Raise In 2027
At a glance

The $6.50 Part B increase is deducted from the Social Security check, so most retirees just see a smaller deposit. The 3.6 percent cost-of-living raise is a percentage while the premium hike is a flat dollar amount, so it bites hardest on the smallest checks — and Part B is only one line in a health care budget that rises faster than the inflation built into the raise.

Newsweek asked how the Medicare Part B premium increase will affect the 2027 Social Security cost-of-living raise, and my comments focused on how that deduction actually reaches people: quietly, inside the check itself. This page explains the reasoning behind those comments.

The deduction most people never see

Most of my retired clients have their Medicare Part B premium deducted from their Social Security check, so they never see the premium as a separate bill. They just see a smaller check each month. Costs like this get noticed more than others because the impact shows up right away, in the deposit, even when the increase itself is modest. The increase is $6.50 a month for most people, $78 for the year.

A percentage raise meets a flat dollar hike

The cost-of-living adjustment is a percentage of each person’s benefit. The Part B premium increase is a flat dollar amount that applies almost equally to everyone. That difference in mechanics matters. Someone with a larger benefit sees a dollar raise that more than covers the higher premium. Someone with a smaller benefit gets a smaller dollar raise, and the same flat premium increase takes a proportionally bigger bite out of it. In pure math, most people come out marginally ahead. The flat rate hike still hits hardest those receiving the smallest Social Security checks, and that nuance is often lost in the shuffle.

Hypothetical example

Consider a hypothetical retired couple whose combined Social Security benefits are modest, with the Part B premium for each of them deducted from their checks. Their 2027 raise is calculated as a percentage of benefits that are already on the smaller side, so the dollar increase is small to begin with. The flat premium increase is then deducted for each spouse, and what looked like a raise on paper shrinks to very little by the time the deposits arrive. A neighbor with a much larger benefit, paying the same premium increase, keeps most of a much larger dollar raise. Same announcement, very different January.

Part B is only one line in the health care budget

A smaller Part B increase does not mean health care got cheaper. Seniors also pay for supplemental insurance and drug coverage, and for services Medicare does not cover at all, like dental, vision and hearing care. Health care costs generally rise faster than the economy-wide inflation baked into the cost-of-living calculation, so any relief on the Part B line can get whittled away elsewhere. It is also worth remembering that this year’s increase looks small partly because it follows last year’s much bigger hike.

Questions readers should ask

  • Is my Part B premium deducted from my Social Security check, and what will my actual net deposit be in January?
  • How much of my raise does the premium increase absorb, given the size of my benefit?
  • What are my total health care costs doing this year, including supplemental coverage, drug coverage, and dental, vision and hearing?
  • If my income has dropped since the tax return Medicare used, should I ask about my income-related premium amount?
  • Does my retirement spending plan assume my full raise, or the amount that actually arrives?

Health care costs are almost always the deciding factor in whether a retirement plan works, so they are worth a fresh look every year, not just in years with a big premium headline. Read the original article on Newsweek. This page is educational and is not individualized tax or investment advice.