The planning considerations behind my comments on choosing a retirement account while on Social Security

In retirement, the account you withdraw from can matter almost as much as how much you saved. A qualified Roth IRA withdrawal does not raise provisional income or Medicare IRMAA, while a traditional IRA withdrawal does. Withdrawal order matters, and Roth conversions work best in slices in lower-income years, modeled year by year.
MoneyLion asked financial experts which retirement account works best once Social Security benefits begin, and my comments focused on one idea: in retirement, the account you withdraw from can matter almost as much as how much you saved. This page explains the reasoning behind those comments.
Why the Roth IRA gets so much attention
A qualified Roth IRA withdrawal is not included in the provisional income calculation the IRS uses to decide whether Social Security benefits are taxable. It also does not count toward the income Medicare uses to set IRMAA surcharges, which are based on a tax return from two years earlier. That combination gives a retiree flexibility. In a year with a big expense, a new roof or a car, you can pull from the Roth without setting off a tax chain reaction. And because a Roth IRA has no required distributions during the owner’s lifetime, it can be the last money you touch.
The other side of the ledger
Traditional IRA withdrawals are taxable as ordinary income, and they raise provisional income. If combined income passes $25,000 for a single filer or $32,000 for a married couple filing jointly, part of the benefit becomes taxable; above $34,000 or $44,000, up to 85 percent can be taxable. One extra dollar of IRA income can drag more of your benefit into taxable territory at the same time, so the real tax rate on that dollar is higher than your bracket suggests. Withdrawal order is therefore a planning decision, not an afterthought.
A hypothetical example
Consider a hypothetical married couple, both retired, with Social Security benefits and a large traditional IRA. In a year when they need an extra $30,000 for a roof and a car, taking the full amount from the traditional IRA raises their provisional income and can pull a larger share of their benefits into taxable income, with a possible Medicare premium effect two years later. Taking part from the Roth IRA instead can meet the same need while keeping provisional income lower. The right split depends on their full tax picture, which is why this is modeled year by year rather than decided once.
On Roth conversions
A Roth conversion is not free. The amount converted is taxed as income that year, and a large conversion can itself tax more of your benefits and raise your Medicare premiums two years later. Done well, in slices, in lower-income years, a conversion fills up a bracket instead of blowing through it. Done in one giant lump, people can convert their way into the very problem they were trying to avoid.
Questions worth asking
- Which of my accounts will I draw from first, and what does that do to the taxation of my Social Security benefits?
- How close is my combined income to the thresholds where 50 percent or 85 percent of benefits become taxable?
- Would a series of smaller Roth conversions in lower-income years cost less tax than one large conversion?
- How will this year’s withdrawals affect my Medicare premiums two years from now?
- When do my required minimum distributions begin, and how large will they be?
The best account depends on your full tax picture, so it is worth reviewing your withdrawal plan before taking a large distribution or making a conversion. Read the original article on MoneyLion. This page is educational and is not individualized tax or investment advice.
Want to talk about your plan?
Book a complimentary 20-minute introductory call. No obligation, no pressure, just a conversation about where you are and what comes next.