The planning considerations behind my comments on finding a financial adviser in retirement
Finding a good adviser in retirement is a skill, and it is learnable. Check the adviser’s credentials and public record first. Understand exactly how they are paid. Insist on a fiduciary. Look for real depth in the retirement questions: Social Security timing, Medicare, taxes on withdrawals, and the order you spend accounts down. Then interview at least two advisers and notice who asks you the better questions.
MarketWatch Picks recently quoted me in “Retired and looking for a financial adviser? This is the art of finding a good one”, by Alisa Wolfson. Choosing an adviser is one of the largest financial decisions a retired person makes, and most people get almost no guidance on how to make it. An article has to keep any one voice brief, so here is the fuller thinking behind my comments, and the homework I would want a reader to do on any adviser, including me.
Start with the record, not the personality
Every adviser leaves a public paper trail, and checking it is free. Registered investment advisers file Form ADV, which sets out their services, how they charge, and any disciplinary history, and the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site lets anyone read it. BrokerCheck does the same for brokers. I tell prospective clients to look me up before our first meeting, and I mean it. An adviser who is uncomfortable with you reading their regulatory record has told you something important. Credentials matter too, but read them correctly: designations show training, while registration and the ADV show how the adviser is actually regulated and whether anything in their history needs explaining.
Know how the adviser is paid, and insist on a fiduciary
The most important question in the first meeting is also the simplest: how do you get paid, and by whom. An adviser paid only by the client has one set of loyalties. An adviser paid commissions by product companies has another, and the products tend to follow the pay. Get the answer in writing, and compare it against the firm’s Form ADV and Form CRS, which every registered firm must give you. Then ask whether the adviser is a fiduciary, legally bound to put your interests ahead of their own, at all times and not just during a sale. That standard, plus a clear answer on pay, tells you more about the relationship you are entering than any brochure.
Retirement is its own specialty
A good adviser for a 40 year old accumulator is not automatically a good adviser for a 68 year old drawing income. Retirement raises questions that accumulation never does: when to claim Social Security, how Medicare premiums interact with your income, which account to spend from first so the tax bill stays low, and how required distributions change the picture after 73. Ask the adviser to walk you through how they handle those questions for clients like you. You are listening for specifics, not slogans. And interview more than one adviser. The right one asks you as many questions as you ask them, explains things in plain language, and never rushes you toward a signature.
A hypothetical example
Hypothetical example: Consider a retired couple, both 67, meeting two advisers. The first leads with performance charts and a product they describe as perfect for retirees, and never asks about the couple’s pension, their health, or when each spouse claimed Social Security. The second starts with questions, explains in writing how the firm is paid, encourages the couple to read its Form ADV and check its record, and maps out a withdrawal order across their accounts before mentioning investments at all. The couple cannot judge future returns, and neither can anyone else. They can judge process, transparency, and fit, and on those three the second adviser wins easily. These details are illustrative only, not a description of any specific person or firm.
Questions worth asking any adviser
Before you decide, ask each adviser the same questions and compare the answers:
- Are you a fiduciary at all times, and will you put that in writing?
- How exactly are you paid, and what will my total cost be each year?
- Can I read your Form ADV and Form CRS before we meet again?
- Have you or your firm ever been disciplined, and can I check that myself?
- How do you handle Social Security timing, Medicare costs, and the tax side of withdrawals?
- If I become a client, who exactly will I talk to, and how often will we review the plan?
If you would like a second set of eyes on your own answers, I am glad to talk it through.
Want to talk about your plan?
Book a complimentary 20-minute introductory call. No obligation, no pressure, just a conversation about where you are and what comes next.