The planning considerations behind my comments on the 2027 Social Security cost of living adjustment
The 2027 Social Security cost of living adjustment is 3.6 percent, and because it is a percentage, the dollar increase depends on the size of your benefit, which is why California retirees see the largest average increase and Montana the smallest. A COLA is designed to track a general inflation index. It is not designed to match any one household’s actual costs, and for most retirees Social Security is only one component of income. The planning work is in the gap between the two.
SSBCrack News recently carried my comments in “2027 Social Security COLA: California Retirees Set for Biggest Average Increase, Montana the Smallest“. My comments were first given to The Independent, and the article sets out what the 3.6 percent adjustment means state by state. An article has to keep any one voice brief, so here is the fuller thinking behind my comments, and the questions I would want a reader to walk away with.
One percentage, fifty different raises
The headline numbers can look strange at first glance. How can the same 3.6 percent produce an average increase of about $375 a month in California and about $298 in Montana? Because a cost of living adjustment is a percentage of an existing benefit, and average benefits differ by state, reflecting the earnings histories of the people who live there. The percentage is national. The dollars are personal. That is also why your own increase will almost certainly not match any state average: it will be 3.6 percent of your benefit, whatever that is, and your benefit is the product of your own working life.
The index is general; your inflation is not
When I said COLAs are designed to keep up with increases in the cost of living as measured by an inflation indicator, this is the point I was making. The adjustment follows a broad government price index. No index knows your life. If your spending is weighted toward the things rising fastest, housing, health care and food among them, your personal inflation rate can run ahead of the official one, and the adjustment will feel smaller than it looks. That is not a flaw anyone can fix from the outside. It is a fact to plan around, which is why I say the increase may not fully offset the expenses that weigh heaviest in a retiree’s budget.
Social Security is one component, not the plan
For most of the families I work with, Social Security is one component of retirement income, alongside savings, investments and sometimes a pension. That framing matters for two reasons. First, it sets the COLA in proportion: welcome, and worth having, but not the thing your standard of living stands or falls on. Second, a larger benefit interacts with the rest of the plan. More Social Security income can mean more of your benefit is taxable, because the income thresholds that decide how much of your benefit is taxed are not adjusted for inflation. It can also affect Medicare premium surcharges and the tax cost of Roth conversions. None of that makes the raise bad news. It means the raise deserves a place in the plan, not just a place in the bank account.
Questions worth asking about your own COLA
- Do I know my actual new benefit amount for January, rather than the state average in the headlines?
- Which of my own expenses rose faster than 3.6 percent this year, and by how much?
- Does the higher benefit change how much of my Social Security is taxable, or my Medicare premiums?
- Is Social Security my main income source or one component, and is that balance still the right one?
- Have I revisited my withdrawal plan since the adjustment was announced?
If you would like a second set of eyes on how the adjustment fits your own plan, I am glad to talk it through.
Author: David Kassir, Managing Director of Manna Wealth Management
Last reviewed: November 13, 2026
David Kassir, Managing Director of Manna Wealth Management, an SEC-registered fiduciary wealth management firm. Educational information, not individualized advice.
A hypothetical example
Hypothetical example: Consider a retired couple receiving a combined $3,900 a month from Social Security. The 3.6 percent adjustment adds about $140 a month, roughly $1,680 over the year. Their actual costs, though, are concentrated in property costs, groceries and a supplemental health policy, which together rose faster than the general index, adding closer to $210 a month. The honest summary is that they gained ground on paper and lost a little ground in practice. Their response is not to complain about the adjustment but to rebalance the plan around it: revisit the withdrawal order across their accounts, check whether the higher benefit changes the tax picture on their IRA withdrawals, and trim discretionary spending early rather than drift. These figures are illustrative only, not a prediction or a recommendation for any specific person.