The planning considerations behind my comments on Medicare choices for federal retirees
For federal retirees, the Medicare option with the lowest premium is often not the lowest-cost option. The honest comparison includes out-of-pocket costs, access to your doctors, the one-time Medigap enrollment window, and IRMAA, the income-related surcharge that follows your tax return from two years earlier.
MoneyLion recently quoted me in “3 Medicare Options Federal Retirees Face in 2027“, on which coverage option costs federal retirees the least in 2027. An article has to keep any one voice brief, so here is the fuller thinking behind my comments, and the questions I would want a reader to walk away with.
Why I do not start with the premium
When people ask me what the cheapest Medicare option is, they usually mean the lowest premium. The premium is just the entry fee. Your real cost of coverage is the premium plus what you pay when you actually use care: copays on a Medicare Advantage plan, or deductibles and coinsurance on Original Medicare. Advantage plans advertise low, sometimes zero, premiums, and then you pay as you go, inside a network, often with prior authorizations standing between you and a treatment your doctor ordered. A Medigap plan usually carries a higher premium, and in exchange it makes your costs predictable and lets you see virtually any doctor who takes Medicare patients. Neither answer is right for everyone. The cheapest option for one household can be the most expensive for another, because the total depends on the care you need, the doctors you see, and the prescriptions you take.
The window that does not reopen
There is one timing point I wish more retirees heard before they choose. If you pass on a Medigap plan during your initial enrollment period, you can be subject to medical underwriting if you try to buy one later. That means an insurer can charge you more, or turn you down, based on your health at that later date. Choosing an Advantage plan at 65 because the premium is low can quietly close a door you may want at 72, when your health and your priorities have changed. Whatever you choose, choose it knowing which doors it keeps open and which ones it closes.
The surcharge set two years earlier
The cost almost nobody factors in is IRMAA, the income-related monthly adjustment amount added to Part B and Part D premiums for higher-income retirees. Medicare generally uses your tax return from two years earlier to set it. So a one-time income event at 63, selling a home, taking a large distribution, or doing a sizable Roth conversion, can raise your Medicare premiums at 65, long after the event itself is over. The clients I work with who plan their year-to-year income on purpose, spreading conversions and gains across years instead of stacking them into one, typically pay less for the exact same coverage than those who do not. The coverage is identical. The planning is the difference.
Questions worth asking about your own coverage
- Are you comparing total costs, premiums plus realistic out-of-pocket spending, or premiums alone?
- Do your doctors, and the specialists you are likely to need, participate in the plan you are considering?
- If you choose Medicare Advantage now, do you understand what medical underwriting could mean if you want Medigap later?
- What did your tax return look like two years ago, and is an IRMAA surcharge likely headed your way?
- Do you have a one-time income event coming, a home sale, a business sale, a large Roth conversion, that should be timed or spread with your future Medicare premiums in mind?
- How much do you value predictability? For many retirees, a known monthly cost is worth more than a lower premium with uncertain bills.
If you would like a second set of eyes on your own plan, I am glad to talk it through.
Author: David Kassir, Managing Director of Manna Wealth Management
Last reviewed: November 10, 2026
David Kassir, Managing Director of Manna Wealth Management, an SEC-registered fiduciary wealth management firm. Educational information, not individualized advice.
A hypothetical example
Hypothetical example: Consider a retired federal couple, both turning 65, in good health, with a strong preference for keeping their longtime doctors. Option one is a Medicare Advantage plan with a $0 premium. Their first year is inexpensive, until one of them needs a specialist who is out of network and a procedure that requires prior authorization, and their out-of-pocket costs climb into the thousands. Option two is Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, at an illustrative $200 per person per month in premium. It costs more every single month, including the healthy ones, and in return their covered care costs them close to nothing beyond the premiums, with no network to check. Now add one planning detail: at 63, this couple did one large Roth conversion in a single year. Because IRMAA looks back two years, that single decision raised both of their Part B and Part D premiums at 65. Spreading the same conversion across three years could have kept them under the surcharge threshold. Same coverage, same conversion, very different total cost. These figures are illustrative only, not a quote for any specific plan.